July 13, 2024

Cheapskate Awards given to “uncaring” councils propping up league of shame

Pendine Academy of Social Care. Mario Kreft MBE at the launch in Wrexham.

A “terrible ten” local authorities are being presented with Cheapskate Awards for paying the lowest care home fees in Wales amid the coronavirus crisis.

They’re being awarded by Care Forum Wales who say the biggest difference between the highest and lowest weekly fee per person is more than £12,000 a year  – equivalent to nearly £500,000 in a care home with 40 residents over a 12 month period.

The “league table of shame” was revealed by the organisation which represents more than 450 social care providers in Wales and they are writing to all the members of the Senedd to point out the unfairness of the system.

According to Care Forum Wales chair Mario Kreft MBE, the huge gulf between the top and the bottom payers was evidence of an unfair post code lottery which was threatening the well-being of the nation’s most vulnerable people and the future of social care in Wales.

The First Minister, Mark Drakeford MS, had admitted the sector was fragile even before the Covid-19 pandemic struck and Mr Kreft is concerned that many care homes across Wales will not survive.

Care Forum Wales say the root of the problem is that for more than 20 years the social care sector has been managed and funded separately by the 22 local councils and the seven health boards in Wales which was a recipe for disaster.

They are calling for an urgent national action plan to sort out the mess and ensure fair funding for social care across Wales.

Currently bottom of the heap in terms of funding is Powys County Council who increased the weekly fee for a person in a residential EMI care home for older people with mental frailty by 2.2 per cent to £559.

In contrast, providers in Cardiff – where fees were already higher – will receive £793.48 a week for providing exactly the same level of service, a four per cent increase that works out as £12,192.96 more for every resident than in Powys over the course of a year.

Even in Cardiff, says Mr Kreft, the fees do not cover the true cost of care and are on average £100 less than the amount paid by people receiving care privately.

Five of the bottom 10 payers are the North Wales councils in Flintshire, Denbighshire, Anglesey, Wrexham and Gwynedd who are joined by Neath Port Talbot, Swansea, Carmarthenshire and Ceredigion.

Just behind Cardiff at the top of the table are Torfaen Council followed by rising star Pembrokeshire who have increased their fees by a minimum of 12.8 per cent and up to 16.5 per cent this yar.

The best-paying North Wales authority is Conwy who are the only North Wales council to pay above the Welsh  average weekly fee.

Newport negotiate separately with individual providers so it was not possible to include them in the table but they are in line with the generally higher rates paid in the South East of Wales.

Mr Kreft said: “The aim of the Cheapskate Awards is to highlight the really serious problems created by a crazy fee structure here in Wales

“Some of these figures really amount to a kick in the teeth to dedicated people who have been showing tremendous courage as well as skill and kindness in the face of a frightening disease during this deadly global pandemic.

“Are vulnerable people in Cardiff really worth £12,000  a year more than equally fragile people in Powys? Let’s face it, Powys are not the only offenders here, sadly their rates merely reflect the disdain shown to social care in many other part of Wales. If that’s the case, our values as a nation are completely wrong.

“This mess has come about because the market has been mis-managed by the 22 local authorities in Wales for more than two decades of devolution.

“As the First Minister himself pointed out, the social care sector was in  a fragile state well before the pandemic and what we are calling for is an urgent national action plan which can ensure fairness and equity in the system, and it’s patently neither.

“We need to build a sustainable care system that will truly be an effective scaffold for the NHS.

“We have a similar postcode lottery in relation to the funding provided by health boards across Wales, so this is one almighty mess with essentially 29 varieties on a theme. It doesn’t make any sense at all.

“The system is completely dysfunctional and has resulted in the sector suffering years of chronic underfunding since it was introduced.

“We were seeing care homes and nursing homes closing across Wales even before the Covid-19  pandemic.

“It is hard to see how many care providers can continue in business with fees at this level and they really represent an insult not just to the staff but also to the 20,000 care home residents across Wales.

“We do welcome the commitment of authorities like Cardiff, Torfaen and Pembrokeshire for recognising the care, dedication and skill of care staff who have been in the front line of the battle against Covid-19.

“I am personally saddened that in 1996 the then Clwyd County Council was the best paying authority for care homes in the whole of Wales and now were are no better than also-rans.

“Not only do we underpin the NHS, the sector is a social and financial cornerstone for communities across Wales. It should be regarded as a treasured national asset and treated accordingly.

“Social care is part of the foundation economy and, given the appropriate level of support, can help lead the economic recovery in Wales.

“What we need as a matter of urgency is a national action plan to sort out the total hotch podge of fees so what we can provide the care that our vulnerable people deserve.

“Social care should not be seen as a cost to society but rather as an asset that represents all that is best in our nation, notably its wonderful workforce.”

League of Shame

Region LA Res Res EMI Nursing Nursing EMI Average for LA
C&V Cardiff 737.89 793.48 730.08 786.99 762.11
Gwent Torfaen 659.94 724.58 690.75 723.31 699.65
W Wales Pembs 652.00 709.00 665.00 721.00 686.75
Gwent Blaenau 612.00 702.00 674.00 716.00 676.00
Gwent Monmouthshire 632.00 704.00 668.00 692.00 674.00
C&V Vale of Glam 634.60 702.04 634.60 702.04 668.32
CMT Rhondda CT 638.00 676.00 645.00 682.00 660.25
CTM Merthyr 585.00 650.00 649.73 696.73 645.37
N Wales Conwy 586.00 636.00 661.00 698.00 645.25
Gwent Caerphilly 615.00 671.00 612.00 675.00 643.25
CTM Bridgend 612.00 653.00 632.00 673.00 642.50
N Wales Gwynedd 566.30 629.33 653.52 689.80 634.74
W Wales Ceredigion 605.00 645.00 617.00 657.00 631.00
N Wales Wrexham 585.72 609.91 634.10 670.38 625.03
N Wales Anglesey 576.00 609.91 634.10 670.38 622.60
N Wales Denbighshire 566.31 609.01 634.10 670.38 619.95
N Wales Flintshire 583.44 607.53 624.37 660.53 618.97
W Wales Carms 594.39 626.52 575.56 663.40 614.97
Swansea Bay Swansea 564.00 564.00 640.00 664.00 608.00
Swansea Bay Neath PT 593.26 600.50 593.26 600.50 596.88
Powys Powys 539.00 559.00 544.00 580.00 555.50
All Wales average 606.56 651.51 638.67 680.59 644.34
Annual difference between highest and lowest   10342.28 12192.96 9676.16 10763.48 10743.72  

Newport negotiate with individual providers and it was not possible to include them in the table.